Now, I Don't Claim to Be an A Student
Daughter reeled away from the kitchen table, where she had been reading.
"May I have some pudding?" she croaked.
Usually I'm no great fan of the first meal of the day being dessert, but she had gotten up on a Saturday morning and, without complaining, grabbed a book she had to read for a class, sat down at the table and got to work. That merited something. When you factored in what she was reading, that merited pudding. I spooned some out. She leaned against the counter and inhaled it.
I said sympathetically, "I know. I believe I also told you in advance you would not actually enjoy this book."
She sighed, "You didn't tell me how bad it was."
I said brightly, "Oh, but aren't you enjoying the scintillating plot? The believable characters? Come on, there's all that sparkling dialogue."
I was finding this too hilarious so I stopped. I composed myself. The kid looked unmoved.
"Mom, has anyone, anywhere, actually liked Pilgrim's Progress?"
"Well, the March girls. But come to think of it, they're fictional. Your teacher must like it. I mean, you're reading it."
She shook her head and added more pudding to her bowl.
"I get the feeling she hates it, too. But she thinks it's important or something." Her face slid into horror.
"AND I HAVE TO WRITE A PAPER ON IT."
I patted her shoulder sympathetically. We've all confronted the boring, irrelevant, mystifingly important book -- that hellish goulash of tedious, obvious, obtuse and annoying prose that some well-meaning English teacher has nevertheless decided separates us from the animals. I'd have told Daughter: "Some day, you'll come to appreciate 'Pilgrim's Progress" but I made a promise I would never lie to my child about important matters.
My question to you: If you were Ruler of the Word, what books would you sentence to anonymity? I'm not saying we're going to burn these works; we're not those people. I'm just suggesting that if there was a product that dismayed 99.94% of its potential market, we'd probably stop foisting it upon people. At the very least, we'd have a special list of "This book is chewy and will probably not give you any actual pleasure" titles. Books on this list might appeal to those people who prefer their triathlons in the driving rain.
So, what's your Beastly Bad Book?
"May I have some pudding?" she croaked.
Usually I'm no great fan of the first meal of the day being dessert, but she had gotten up on a Saturday morning and, without complaining, grabbed a book she had to read for a class, sat down at the table and got to work. That merited something. When you factored in what she was reading, that merited pudding. I spooned some out. She leaned against the counter and inhaled it.
I said sympathetically, "I know. I believe I also told you in advance you would not actually enjoy this book."
She sighed, "You didn't tell me how bad it was."
I said brightly, "Oh, but aren't you enjoying the scintillating plot? The believable characters? Come on, there's all that sparkling dialogue."
I was finding this too hilarious so I stopped. I composed myself. The kid looked unmoved.
"Mom, has anyone, anywhere, actually liked Pilgrim's Progress?"
"Well, the March girls. But come to think of it, they're fictional. Your teacher must like it. I mean, you're reading it."
She shook her head and added more pudding to her bowl.
"I get the feeling she hates it, too. But she thinks it's important or something." Her face slid into horror.
"AND I HAVE TO WRITE A PAPER ON IT."
I patted her shoulder sympathetically. We've all confronted the boring, irrelevant, mystifingly important book -- that hellish goulash of tedious, obvious, obtuse and annoying prose that some well-meaning English teacher has nevertheless decided separates us from the animals. I'd have told Daughter: "Some day, you'll come to appreciate 'Pilgrim's Progress" but I made a promise I would never lie to my child about important matters.
My question to you: If you were Ruler of the Word, what books would you sentence to anonymity? I'm not saying we're going to burn these works; we're not those people. I'm just suggesting that if there was a product that dismayed 99.94% of its potential market, we'd probably stop foisting it upon people. At the very least, we'd have a special list of "This book is chewy and will probably not give you any actual pleasure" titles. Books on this list might appeal to those people who prefer their triathlons in the driving rain.
So, what's your Beastly Bad Book?